blog-header
Click here to subscribe

The Best Bottled Water? Just Ask a Water Taster

Connect with me on

I’ve been busy tasting the water equivalent of grand crus (the highest wine classification).

I’m not a drinker so I miss out on the perpetual wine tastings my friends enjoy – pouring the liquid gently, swirling it in a glass, checking the film on top, smelling it, examining its clarity and transparency, running it across my tongue and tasting it…

Picking the best bottled water - a water taster

Lawrence (right) does the honors while I scribble furiously

Now I can do it too. With water.

And each brand does have its own taste – although at first I didn’t believe a word of it.

I’m in the bar of the Hotel Les Cygnes at Lake Geneva’s edge, in a small town – Evian-les-Bains – that has been bottling water for more than a century.

Across from me, Lawrence Duval uncaps one of several plastic water bottles and slowly pours the liquid into a wineglass under the discreet gaze of waiters more accustomed to pouring wine than water into glasses this size.

Well… looks just like – water.

“You start with two balloon wineglasses, washed by hand, not by dishwasher,” explains Lawrence. “Natural light is best, with a white background to better see the color of the water. And the water has to be at room temperature.”

At first I was amused but water tasting is serious business, one that involves hours of initial training followed by extensive practice. You can take a short course over three days but you will then have to work at it.

“Someone once bet me publicly at a press conference that I couldn’t tell bottled waters apart. But I did,” she said. “You need to use all five senses, and you start with eyesight.” As the person in charge of water and wellbeing for the Rhône-Alpes tourism board, Lawrence knows what she’s talking about, since this region produces the bulk of France’s bottled water.

A Guide to Water Tasting

Water tasting may be considered an art but in fact there is a science to it.

Like a sommelier, a water taster will look at color – whether it is pearly, or has bluish tints – and appearance, like dullness or brilliance.

Then there’s touch, which takes place inside the mouth, where you ‘feel’ for chemicals or astringency, not quite the same as tasting.

Of course, smell is involved: like wines, each water has its own, although less marked. To get under a water’s aroma you’ll have to breathe through your nose and allow the scent to waft through your nostrils into your upper airways.

Hearing is also used in tasting bottled water, but only when it sparkles: you listen to the clean sound of bubbles (or the effervescence, if you prefer the more technical term).

Finally, there’s taste, and waters present a range of flavors: woody, spicy, flowery, fruity, chemical, smoky… By working with a professional water taster and taking your time, you’ll easily learn to tell these tastes apart.

I did, and I was surprised.

Evian kiosk water source

The source of Evian once led to this little building, where people gathered a century ago to sip the waters

Water-Food Pairing: A Match Made in Heaven

Like wine, specific waters work best with certain foods.

“The flat waters of the region are quite different from one another,” said Lawrence. “Thonon water is quite sweet – it works best with desserts or with chocolate, while Evian is a bit astringent so it’s best to drink it with something fatty, like meat or cheese or a sauce.”

Sparkling waters are tasted in the same way and they too are paired with different foods.

“A green Badoit will go well with cheese, while a red Badoit, with its larger bubbles, is much more of a digestive, to be drunk after a meal.”

Choosing the best bottled water means tasting them all first - a professional water taster can help

Tasting water is quite an art

Telling the region’s more than 30 bottled waters apart is a challenge, akin to wine tasting – but a lot more difficult.

“You know, 98% of all wines are identical: 80% water, 12% alcohol and 6% chemical ingredients. So in fact you’re only comparing wines on the remaining 2%.”

That’s food for thought. And it shows how sensitive our taste buds are.

A Short History of Bottled Water

People have been drinking treated water since Egyptian times; we know this from a pharaoh’s tomb at Thebes which depicts water from the Nile being driven through clay pots before drinking.

As for water’s health benefits, they have been known since Antiquity but mineral water hit its apogee in the 18th and 19th centuries, when those who could afford it began ‘taking the waters’ in fashionable corners of Europe.

Water sources spouting out of the mountain were initially free but a few smart businessmen realized money could be made from this health craze and began bottling it.

Take Evian water, born of nearby Alpine glaciers.

A local aristocrat noticed a significant improvement in his liver and kidney ailments after drinking water from a fountain in Evian regularly. He lauded the water’s ‘miracle’ powers left and right and once doctors began prescribing the water to their patients the source’s owner, a certain Mr Cachat, saw he could benefit and fenced the source, bottling and selling the water. The rest is history.

bottled water at turn of century

Mr Cachat’s Evian source

A Stroll Through the Bottled Waters of the Rhône-Alpes

While you once had to travel to the source to ‘take the cure’ and ‘drink the waters’ these days the water comes to you.

It comes in all sizes and shapes and is divided into flat and sparkling, with sparkling water subdivided into natural and carbonated (with gas added).

Each water has its own healing powers: some are good for kidneys, and others for rheumatism or blood circulation or metabolic illnesses.

While drinking is their most obvious use, these same waters are used in thermal spas with even greater benefits because of their concentration and the amount used.

I’m an avid bottled water drinker but I’m also aware of its drawbacks: bottled water is obviously more expensive than tap water; drinking some brands at length may overload your system with certain minerals (but at the same time save you from metals present in plumbing); and not all bottles are returnable or biodegradable so environmental concerns should be addressed.

I live in France and each year I try to spend a week at a thermal spa (and when that doesn’t work out I at least try to have a decent spa treatment). Longer preventive thermal treatments are so common that the country’s socialized medical system actually pays for three-week cures (I’m afraid I haven’t benefited).

Not All Bottled Water is the Same

Like most people in my region, I have my water preferences – here are just a few of the most common.

Aix: try this as an aperitif, before your meal. It is aromatic so you might lose its scent if you combine it with a meal.

Arcens: Definitely for spicy food or complicated dishes.

Evian: Salty and best with fatty foods.

Green Label Badoit: Fizzy and sharp and perfect with cheese. Used to be natural but now has a little gas added to it.

Red Label Badoit: Big, fat bubbles that will wipe away any trace of grease on your mouth. Utterly carbonated.

Thonon: Sweetness that goes with fruit and dessert (and chocolate!)

Vals: The perfect picnic water.

Me? I’m a Green Badoit girl.

Having attended a demonstration by a trained water taster and learned how to pair water with food, I’ll never look at a bottle of water the same way again.

Do you have a bottled water preference? Let me know in the Comments below.

Things you should know

  • Mineral waters of the region can be found mostly in two départements: the Haute-Savoie (Evian, Thonon) and the Loire (Badoit)
  • Mineral waters have other uses, notably wellness. Major spas can be found in Evian-les-BainsThonon-les-Bains, and Aix-les-Bains
  • You can visit the Evian water plant from June to September but it’s complicated. You’ll need to make a reservation at the Information Kiosk on the Rue Nationale (+33 450 848029) in Evian-les-Bains and might only get on a tour the following day.
  • Evian and Thonon are right on Lake Geneva, an easy drive from the Geneva airport. You can also take a bus or a (far more expensive) taxi.

This article is part of My Rhône-Alpes, a series in which I explore the stunning region in which I live in Eastern France. Thanks to the tourist offices of Evian-les-Bains, Thonon-les-Bains and the Rhône-Alpes Region for organizing this visit and hosting Women on the Road. Opinions are my own: I’m opinionated and plan to stay that way. Photos by Anne Sterck.

7 Comments

  1. […] is also a great place to sample the waters in other ways – by tasting them: the Rhône-Alpes region has more bottled waters than any other part of […]

  2. Stefania on August 22, 2013 at 1:10 am

    Now that you make me think of it, I didn’t like the water in Slovenia that much.

    • Leyla Giray Alyanak on August 22, 2013 at 6:46 am

      LOL – just more proof that it doesn’t taste the same everywhere!

  3. Les Cygnes, Evian (France) – Women on the Road on September 29, 2013 at 11:56 am

    […] staff pretended not to notice as I had my first ever water-tasting class right in their main bar – and we didn’t even buy the bottles […]

  4. una on October 9, 2013 at 10:18 pm

    Great article, I enjoyed the information as and another reason why there are such a variety of bottled waters is because people have varied tastes.

    • Leyla Giray Alyanak on October 10, 2013 at 7:16 am

      They do have varied tastes – but what I never expected was to find so many different-tasting waters!

  5. […] and in case you thought all water tastes the same, think again; I sampled the different ones with a water sommelier during my […]

Leave a Comment